The Directed Reading Thinking Activity (DRTA) strategy enhances students’ reading comprehension of narrative texts. This research investigates the effectiveness of DRTA in improving the reading skills of eighth-grade students at MTS Miftahul Jannah. The study employs a quasi-experimental design with a control group, analyzing pretest and posttest scores to measure comprehension improvements. Results indicate significant differences in reading comprehension between students taught with DRTA and those who were not. This strategy encourages active engagement with texts, making it beneficial for educators seeking effective teaching methods.

Key Points

  • Explores the impact of DRTA on narrative text comprehension for eighth graders
  • Utilizes a quasi-experimental design with control and experimental groups
  • Includes pretest and posttest assessments to measure reading improvements
  • Demonstrates significant differences in comprehension scores between groups
Ephin Aluni
Author:Ayu Lutfiah Dewi, Ainol, Achmad Kholili
9 pages
Language:English
Type:Research Paper
Ephin Aluni
Author:Ayu Lutfiah Dewi, Ainol, Achmad Kholili
9 pages
Language:English
Type:Research Paper
362
/ 9
Jo-ELT (Journal of English Language Teaching)
Fakultas Keguruan dan Ilmu Pendidikan
Program Studi Pendidikan Bahasa Inggris IKIP
https://e-journal.undikma.ac.id/index.php/joelt
Email: joelt@undikma.ac.id
June 2023, Vol.10 No.1
online: 2548-5865
print: 2355-0309
pp.120-128
doi:10.33394/jo-elt.v10i1.7302
Jo-ELT (Journal of English Language Teaching) Fakultas Pendidikan Bahasa dan Seni
Program Studi Pendidikan Bahasa Inggris IKIP, June 2023. Vol.10 No.1 | Page 120
DIRECTED READING THINKING ACTIVITY (DRTA) STRATEGY ON
STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION OF NARRATIVE TEXT
#1
Ayu Lutfiah Dewi,
*2
Ainol,
*3
Achmad Kholili
#1
English Student, Faculty of Educational Scientific and Teaching, Islamic University of
Zainul Hasan Genggong, Indonesia
*2
English Lecturer, Faculty of Tarbiyah and Teaching, Islamic University of Zainul Hasan
Genggong, Indonesia
*3
English Lecturer, Faculty of Educational Scientific and Teaching, Islamic University of
Zainul Hasan Genggong, Indonesia
Corresponding Author Email: [email protected]
A B S T R A C T S
A R T I C L E I N F O
DRTA is a reading comprehension strategy for students, especially
narrative texts. Balajthy (2003) in his book says Russell Stauffer in 1975
developed the directed reading thinking activity (DRTA) as a more
attractive alternative to the course outline model used in most basic
guided reading courses. The DRTA strategy was advanced to encourage
active reading comprehension and move the student to assume critically
to understand the text. The design of a quasi-experimental with a design
non-equivalent control class was employed since this investigates the
efficacy of using the DRTA strategy for improving students reading
comprehension of the narrative text. The observation, test, and
documentation were collected in this study. The question test consisted
of 20 items using pretest-posttest, in the VIIIA class, which included 22
female students were used as an experimental class, and the VIIIB class,
which included 14 male students was used as the control class. An
independent sample t-test was used to analyze the evidence to find out
whether the DRTA strategy improved the students reading
comprehension. The result showed that the T-test value was 4,698 with
probably Sig two-sided 0,001, the score Sig two-sided 0,001 < 0,05. The
experimental class that received the DRTA strategy differs significantly
from the control class that did not receive treatment. As a result, it will
draw a conclusion that the DRTA strategy is effective for the education
and studying of the activity of eight grade students at the MTS Miftahul
Jannah’s.
Article History:
Received: March, 2023
Revised: May, 2023
Published: June, 2023
018
Keywords:
DRTA,
Reading Comprehension,
Narrative Text,
How to cite: Dewi, A., Ainol, A., & Kholili, A. (2023). Directed Reading Thinking Activity (DRTA) Strategy
on Students’ Reading Comprehension of Narrative Text. Jo-ELT (Journal of English Language Teaching)
Fakultas Pendidikan Bahasa & Seni Prodi Pendidikan Bahasa Inggris IKIP, 10(1), 120-128.
doi:https://doi.org/10.33394/jo-elt.v10i1.7302
INTRODUCTION
Generally, people will not be able to understand information from books, newspaper
essays, and the internet without having good reading skills. Reading is the skill of receiving
information. According to Harmer (2007) is beneficial for language acquisition. Apart from
being useful, reading skills are the key to success in the future and people who want to be
successful in the future must always take the time to keep reading. McNamara (2007)
Reading is one of several teaching formats that convey prior knowledge for future learning.
Dewi
Directed Reading Thinking Activity ………
Jo-ELT (Journal of English Language Teaching) Fakultas Pendidikan Bahasa dan Seni
Program Studi Pendidikan Bahasa Inggris IKIP, June 2023. Vol.10 No.1 | Page 121
Brown (2004) Reading becomes the most crucial skill in any educational setting. Therefore
reading skills are very influential in our lives.
According to Brown (2001), four English skills have to be learned by the student. Such
as communicate by speaking, listening, writing, and reading. Reading, listening, speaking,
and writing are language abilities. Reading is a learning competencies that have to be learned
by students. Snow (2002) defines reading comprehension as a process of interacting with and
simultaneously creating definitions through relationships and written language participation.
Rasinski (2010) definition of comprehension is the act of consciously creating meaning
through dialogue between the reader and the sentence. Reading comprehension is also critical
for improving reading efficiency and enjoyment, as well as for assisting with all other
subjects in life both personally and professionally. Also, it can aid students in understanding
the text’s goal. The student has studied various texts when learning English, especially
narrative text. The text of a narrative is one that explains a series of events in chronological
order or in relation to one another. Narrative texts are typically imaginative, which means
they are not real or exist only in the author’s imagination. A narrative text, according to
Martin (2000), is one in which an agent tells a story. Reading narrative texts is very important
for students because narrative texts are always related to problems in the story and end with
problem-solving, so stories and narrative texts provide students with a lot of moral messages.
However, most students continue to struggle with reading English because they do not
understand the text. Common difficulties are non-Indonesian languages which lead to
difficulties in reading English, lack of vocabulary, mastery of pronunciation, etc. But in
reality, reading is not as easy as it seems. Reading requires a good understanding so that
someone can interpret information correctly. Sometimes students have to read the text twice
or think twice to understand it, even though it takes a lot of time for students. This is
especially useful for students who are not motivated to study. Reading must be too difficult
for students. According to Harmer (2003), students have predicted that the entire experience
will frustrate them and reduce their motivation to learn. This attitude is frequently the result
of illiteracy. This is primarily due to students being assigned reading texts that are too
difficult for them to be interested in, teachers do not generate interest, and students believe
that reading is always boring. The most common causes are usually students who have
difficulty in reading comprehension, namely, lack of confidence, lack of desire from within
them to learn reading comprehension, lack of support from the family, parents, and the most
common thing is students don’t like English and it’s fast. Bored when learning reading
comprehension in class. The causes of students who develop bored quickly are frequently the
consequence of the teacher’s education and science strategies.
Based on observations at the Islamic Junior High School Miftahul Jannah, the
researchers discovered that English teachers continued to use the old method, which only
focused on explanation. As a result of teachers' lack of creativity in adopting learning
methods, students become bored quickly when learning English, resulting in difficulty
reading, a lack of vocabulary, difficulty understanding English texts, and a lack of motivation
to learn to read.
According to the issues raised above, the researcher will use DRTA strategy to address
the issue of reading comprehension in students. DRTA is a strategy that can improve a
student's understanding. Balajthy (2003) in his book says Russell Stauffer in 1975 developed
the directed reading thinking activity (DRTA) as a more appealing alternative to the lesson
plan model used in most basic guided reading courses. The directed reading thinking activity,
approach directs students’ involvement in the text because they have to participate and
demonstrate during reading in class. The Student can find the central textual concept by
learning reading comprehension. According to Arief (2019), DRTA is a reading strategy in
which readers use their personal experience to help the author's concept come to life. The
Dewi
Directed Reading Thinking Activity ………
Jo-ELT (Journal of English Language Teaching) Fakultas Pendidikan Bahasa dan Seni
Program Studi Pendidikan Bahasa Inggris IKIP, June 2023. Vol.10 No.1 | Page 122
DRTA strategy is created to encourage operative comprehension of the text and to encourage
students to think critically in order to comprehend texts.
Several previous studies applying DRTA in the study (Hasan, 2019; Chaemsai, 2016;
Sunarti, 2022; Annida, 2018) find demonstrated the DRTA strategy worked well in
improving students' reading comprehension. DRTA strategy is beneficial to the development
of reading comprehension by students. The point in this research is to determine the impact of
the DRTA on students' reading comprehension at the MTS Miftahul Jannah. The problem
statement is whether or not students who are instructed with the DRTA approach outperform
those who aren’t. The researcher hopes the directed reading thinking activity (DRTA)
strategy will be successful in enhancing comprehension of the text in this study.
RESEARCH METHOD
Research Design
This research is a non-equivalent control class design and a pretest-posttest of quasi-
experimental design. The researcher used a quasi-experimental design because the researcher
did not have the authority to control the sample under study, which meant the researcher did
not have the freedom to choose samples at random. This was due to restrictions in the school
setting. However, in a quasi-experimental design, the researcher takes the experimental
process such as determining the research schedule and choosing types or research
measurements. Donoghue (2013) proposes a quasi-experimental design with control but no
random assignment. This means that experimental concept research is a study without
random assignment.
Population
This study was conducted in the eighth grade at MTS Miftahul Jannah, which consisted
of two classes totaling 36 students, namely class VIIIA and class VIIIB. Class VIIIA was the
control class, totaling 14 male students, and class VIIIB was the experimental class, totaling
22 female students.
Instruments
The observations are made prior to being given an observation test by using an
instrument in the research so that the technique of educating and studying English in the
classroom as well as the methods used by the teacher and can be learned by the researcher.
Furthermore, the study administered tests to students, specifically the pretest-posttest. The
pretest was administered prior to treatment, and the posttest was administered following
treatment. The pretest was given before the treatment and the post-test was given after the
treatment. The pretest is given to find out the students’ basic mastery skills in reading
comprehension while the posttest is to find out the students’ reading ability after being given
treatment. Finally, documentation is used to collect data, such as lists of student names,
student knowledge prior to treatment, and documentation used when conducting research.
The researcher applied the DRTA strategy to the VIIIB student as an experimental class, and
do not give a treatment to the VIIIA as the control class in four meetings. DRTA strategy
greatly assists students during the teaching and studying process on reading, students will
gain extensive knowledge, and students will be able to develop their potential of reading
much more celerity.
Data Analysis
To compute the pretest and the post-test scores on both the experimental and control
class, the quantitative data analysis method was used. SPSS version 29 was used to calculate
the input in this research. To evaluate the hypothesis of the result, this study uses descriptive
/ 9
End of Document
362

FAQs

what is the Directed Reading Thinking Activity (DRTA) strategy

The Directed Reading Thinking Activity (DRTA) strategy is a reading comprehension approach designed to enhance students' understanding of narrative texts.

  • Developed by Russell Stauffer in 1975, it encourages active engagement with the text.
  • Students make predictions about the content before reading, which helps them to focus on key ideas.
  • The strategy promotes critical thinking by requiring students to verify their predictions after reading.

how does the DRTA strategy improve reading comprehension

The DRTA strategy improves reading comprehension by fostering active participation and critical thinking among students.

  • It encourages students to make predictions, which engages their prior knowledge.
  • Students are prompted to interact with the text, enhancing their ability to derive meaning.
  • Research indicates that students using DRTA showed higher post-test scores compared to those who did not.

what are the findings of the DRTA strategy research paper

The research paper on the Directed Reading Thinking Activity (DRTA) strategy found significant improvements in reading comprehension among students.

  • The experimental group using DRTA had an average post-test score of 84.32, while the control group scored 65.36.
  • The independent sample t-test showed a T-value of 4.698 with a significance level of 0.001, indicating a strong effect of the strategy.
  • Overall, the study concluded that DRTA is effective for enhancing narrative text comprehension.

what is the methodology used in the DRTA strategy study

The study on the Directed Reading Thinking Activity (DRTA) employed a quasi-experimental design with a non-equivalent control group.

  • The research involved two classes: one as the experimental group receiving DRTA and the other as a control group.
  • Data was collected through pre-tests and post-tests to assess reading comprehension.
  • Statistical analysis, including independent sample t-tests, was used to evaluate the effectiveness of the strategy.

what are the key components of the DRTA strategy

The key components of the Directed Reading Thinking Activity (DRTA) strategy include prediction, verification, and interaction with the text.

  • Prediction: Students anticipate what the text will be about before reading.
  • Verification: After reading, students check their predictions against the actual content.
  • Interaction: Encourages students to engage with the text actively, leading to deeper understanding.

how does DRTA compare to traditional reading strategies

The Directed Reading Thinking Activity (DRTA) differs significantly from traditional reading strategies by emphasizing active engagement.

AspectDRTATraditional Strategies
EngagementActive participation through predictionsPassive reading and comprehension
Critical ThinkingEncourages questioning and verificationFocuses on memorization
OutcomeImproved comprehension and retentionVariable comprehension levels

what are the benefits of using DRTA in classrooms

Implementing the Directed Reading Thinking Activity (DRTA) in classrooms offers several benefits for students.

  • Enhances reading comprehension skills by promoting critical thinking.
  • Increases student engagement and motivation through interactive learning.
  • Helps students develop a deeper understanding of narrative texts.

what challenges might teachers face with DRTA

While the Directed Reading Thinking Activity (DRTA) strategy has many advantages, teachers may encounter challenges during implementation.

  • Time management can be difficult, as DRTA requires more class time for discussions and activities.
  • Students may struggle with making predictions if they lack prior knowledge.
  • Effective classroom management is essential to maintain focus during interactive sessions.

how can DRTA be adapted for different age groups

The Directed Reading Thinking Activity (DRTA) can be adapted for various age groups by modifying the complexity of the texts and the prediction tasks.

  • For younger students, use simpler narratives with clear storylines.
  • For older students, incorporate more complex texts that require deeper analysis.
  • Adjust prediction activities to match developmental levels, encouraging age-appropriate critical thinking.

what types of texts are best suited for DRTA

The Directed Reading Thinking Activity (DRTA) strategy works best with narrative texts that have engaging plots and characters.

  • Fictional stories that involve conflict and resolution are ideal.
  • Texts that include moral lessons or themes can enhance discussions.
  • Adaptations can also be made for informational texts with clear structures.